My mother always taught me that reading books would help me to get on in life*. You only have to look at my dazzling career to see how right she was. (Funnily enough, people in my old job looked at me like I was stupid because I refused to cite a source without actually plodding along to the library to read it.) My mother’s career is illuminating too, given that in Britain the majority of PAs are better educated than their vastly better paid bosses, and that blacks are paid significantly less than whites with matched qualifications and experience. It is interesting that her boss’s name is the same as his father’s which in turn is identical to that of the firm the latter founded**.
Today’s Economist discusses Britain’s celebrity aristocracy and notes that, in our newly meritocratic society, the people are no longer interested in the “private” affairs of lazy, talentless, and ignorant dukes and duchesses, but those of lazy, talentless, and ignorant commoners. It is illustrated with a photograph of Jordan and Peter Andre. Their skin is the colour of a Space Hopper. In fact Jordan appears to have had two small Space Hoppers surgically attached to her ribcage.
The piece discusses the [whimper] synergistic relationship between the media and the giftless, the overseas expansion of the UK fame industry, and examines coolly how, even for sports stars, actual performance has become detached from earning potential. [Surely not?]
This caught my eye:
“The pop singer and the topless model, better known as Jordan, met when their careers were flagging, on a reality TV show—that essential new cog in the celebrity machine. They have sold rights to the wedding, built around a Cinderella theme, as an exclusive to OK! for a small fortune (a price, the gossip press says, that has irked Victoria Beckham, whose marriage to her footballer husband was covered by a million-pound contract).”
The explanation is simple: the supposedly posh Victoria Beckham has, famously, never read a book; Jordan has at least finished the story of the Yorkshire Ripper. Although both stars’ breasts are thought to contain inorganic polymers, OK! is paying a premium for Jordan’s infinitely greater erudition.
[*I should point out that my mum also taught me to read. This is one of the most wonderful and precious of many wonderful and precious things she has done for me. She taught me to read good English; my dad taught me to write good English. I will be grateful to them until I die.]
[**Enjoy this line now: my mum’ll be on the phone later to tell me to remove it. ]
Actually, I love reading about lazy, talentless, ignorant aristocrats – provided that they behave like aristocrats. Now, they all behave like commoners. This is a great shame.
When my parents first viewed what is now their present house, they noted that the previous owners had just one bookshelf – and I mean shelf in the singular.
However, one of the owners (or users) of said shelf was described by Vogue as “a nascent style diva”, so that was probably more than enough compensation for her evident shortcomings in the book-learnin’ department.
Funnily enough, people in my old job looked at me like I was stupid because I refused to cite a source without actually plodding along to the library to read it.
When I handed in my first degree essay after returning to university as a mature student, I was worried whether or not I’d been conscientious enough in listing every one of my sources – all 48 of them, mostly short newspaper and journal articles, neatly itemised according to the Harvard Referencing System. The guy in front of me in the queue to hand it in showed me his bibliography, which listed one book and the all-encompassing suffix “plus some newspaper and magazine pieces”. I think he dropped out not long afterwards.
Come on, Damian, some sources please:
blacks are paid significantly less than whites with matched qualifications and experience
Not only is this economically stupid (ooh I think I’ll behave suboptimally becuase I’m alergic to melanin) and therefore not likely to succeed long term, it’s illegal.
A beautiful and pure example of exactly this phenomenon was reported in The Economist a few years ago. I have written in the past that I am pleased that top-flight English professional footballers get paid lots of money because, unlike many English executives, the huge rewards the soccer players receive are at least tightly coupled to their performance. However, there is excellent evidence that black footballers in this country have been paid less than they should have been and that teams that are smart enough not to “behave suboptimally because they are allergic to melanin” do rather nicely out of it.
In medicine, all it takes is a change to the apparent ethnicity of the name at the head of a CV and the chances of your even being interviewed for a job as an NHS doctor fall significantly.
And, if you want to look still further down the earnings scale, there’s a surprisingly large number of highly educated West Africans getting paid not very much to be shouted at for giving parking tickets.
If you are prepared to wade through a boring PDF from Number 10 you can try this as well:
I should also point out that, personally, since I stopped being surrounded by bigoted working-class north Midlanders, being beige has been a clear advantage in life; even the downside is better: occasionally being patronised is a massive improvement over occasionally having my teeth knocked out. In fact, I was talking to a woman last weekend who told me that I should join the Conservative Party and put myself forward as a candidate. She said, “You’re just black enough for them: you know the words to Jammin’, but they don’t have to worry that you”ll be arrested for smoking crack.”
[…] Further to my comment about the relative income levels of Whites and ethnic minorities in this country, I should confess that, not only were four out of the forty entrants in this year’s Miss England Muslims, but the winner herself was born in Tashkent of Afghan parents who fled Afghanistan in 1980. The favourite to win, Sarah Mendly, was a refugee from Saddam Hussein. I am shocked, shocked to see these young and talented women flee oppression in their own countries only to become victims of this sexist and exploitative “competition”. “Islamic leaders” agreed with me: […]
Thanks for the sources. It shows that in the long run a genuinely free market in labour will get rid of this kind of inequality – some cognitive dissonance for Guardian readers in that one.
Also nice to see Ron Knee as a progressive ahead of the BMA/consultants. Probably has a lot to do with its being easier to hide death rates than goals scored.
Thanks also for the Prefabs reference. Under-appreciated, much missed.
No it doesn’t. It shows that, even in one of the very few near-textbook free markets for labour, irrational behaviour is sustainable for decades, far longer than most participants’ useful working lives—provided enough people in that market are stupid.
Free markets are not a cure for mass stupidity; they are just more efficient at delivering the damage it does than non-free ones. If the majority of customers prefer to be served dinner by all-black waiting staff and send their children to all-white schools then un-regulated free markets in catering and education will ensure that they get what they want.
Now that I agree with.
I disagree. Arsenal thive, Scunthorpe United sink. The only reason the Scunners are still around is because the lower leagues are subsidised by the Premier league – i.e. it’s not a completely free market.
Free markets are indeed not a cure for stupidity but they sure penalize it. Yes, this can take time.
Make your mind up. It was a free market two comments ago when it suited your argument and now it’s not? Are you an unreconstructed Tory by any chance?
I’m talking about the market for players. Chelsea didn’t win the Premiership last season because the club’s coach selected players who wanted to do their best for south west London. It won because it had more money to spend on talent than any other side in country, and the talent followed the money—much to the irritation of the competition.
Only a true believer in the sacred wisdom of the Invisible Hand could write that under a post about Jordan and Peter Andre’s massive earnings.
In fact Jordan appears to have had two small Space Hoppers surgically attached to her ribcage.
Actually, those are meerkat dens. They allow a pair of the cute little mongeeses to be on permanent lookout for snakes and other predators.
[…] is implied by Chris’s musings on the matter, markets are not the solution to this problem. As I’ve pointed out here before, well-run markets don’t undermine prejudices, they’re just an efficient means for […]